HomeForumsTechnical – GeneralEngineHelp with 5L to LS Water Temp Sensor

This topic contains 42 replies, has 6 voices, and was last updated by Profile photo of VRSenator065 VRSenator065 8 years, 11 months ago.

Viewing 20 posts - 21 through 40 (of 43 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #11237
    Profile photo of Immortality
    Immortality
    Participant
    Member since: August 31, 2015
    Posts: 535

    Yea agreed, whats the old saying, “an oil pressure gauge tells you when the engine is about to blow up, a temperature gauge tells you when it already has….” Actually I reckon that could be a really neat solution. I could then just extend and run the wire down in the original loom on the side of the bay and down the side of the radiator to it. Cheers for that, I reckon that’s a plan

     

    I think that about covers it, I’ve just about dumped all the coolant in the Senator and the dash gauge didn’t move, fortunately I had stopped to check something completely different and noticed it was hot when I lifted the bonnet.  Engine did make a horrible ticking noise from around one of the rear cylinder for a bit but nothing blew up.

     

    I think having the temp sender in the bottom hose is going to delay the noticeable change in coolant temperature even longer than the standard location.  Ideally it needs to be a close as possible to the thermostat where the highest temps are normally seen.

    #11239
    Profile photo of
    Anonymous Member since: January 1, 1970
    Posts: 0

    I think it will work opposite, if there’s a leak having a sender at the lowest point is going to show a spike in temp as the coolant drains, sender at the top as you found soon as it’s uncovered there’s little to no reading on the temp gauge..

    #11240
    Profile photo of cava454
    cava454
    Moderator
    Member since: February 20, 2015
    Posts: 2 390
    Supporter

    When I had the sender in bottom hose if I was on fwy it would sit on 150/160F. Because the coolant in the radiator was so cool. Then out of no where the t/stat would open and the gauge would bounce straight to 210.

     

    only way I believe the bottom hose would come close to being accurate would be if there was no t/stat.

    #11241
    Profile photo of
    Anonymous Member since: January 1, 1970
    Posts: 0

    LOL never said it was going to be accurate…

    Just in Gary’s case he doesn’t want to cut his top hose…

    (I’d cut the hose)  B-)

    #11242
    Profile photo of VRSenator065
    VRSenator065
    Participant
    • Adelaide SA
    • VR Senator LSx454 1960 Kombi (project) 1921 Nash Hot Rod (future project)

    • View build HERE
    Member since: February 17, 2015
    Posts: 5 777
    Supporter

    But as IJ has said its not about being accurate in reading an actual temperature, lets face it Holden gauges are woeful, no two read the same.  Its about watching for fluctuations/variations.  I have just gone out and bought an adapter for the hose, will fit it tomorrow and have a look.

    #11244
    Profile photo of Immortality
    Immortality
    Participant
    Member since: August 31, 2015
    Posts: 535

    My theory is that as long as there is some coolant in the system and no airlock in the bottom hose it (the water pump) will continue to suck coolant from the radiator and force it into the engine so it (the engine) won’t show a major temperature fluctuation until all the coolant is lost in which case by the time you notice it will probably to late anyway.

    In reality, how often do you notice a change in engine temperature?  How often do you check the gauge whilst you drive?  If you want a 100% fool proof method you really need to set up a bright warning light that illuminates at a set temp.

    A much better option would be a low coolant sensor but Holden’s have never had such a thing unfortunately.

    #11245
    Profile photo of
    Anonymous Member since: January 1, 1970
    Posts: 0

    I have a scan gauge II in my daily and keep an eye on actual temps, the Holden gauge shows little to no movement across a 10c range around operating temp so Joe Average doesn’t freak out in traffic…

    If the coolant is low everything at the top of the engine is steam which doesn’t register as a temp or the needle would be in the red, by this stage it’s usually already too late as it only takes 400c to anneal aluminium..

    Agreed a low level sensor would be perfect.

    #11247
    Profile photo of cava454
    cava454
    Moderator
    Member since: February 20, 2015
    Posts: 2 390
    Supporter

    My theory is that as long as there is some coolant in the system and no airlock in the bottom hose it (the water pump) will continue to suck coolant from the radiator and force it into the engine so it (the engine) won’t show a major temperature fluctuation until all the coolant is lost in which case by the time you notice it will probably to late anyway. In reality, how often do you notice a change in engine temperature? How often do you check the gauge whilst you drive? If you want a 100% fool proof method you really need to set up a bright warning light that illuminates at a set temp. A much better option would be a low coolant sensor but Holden’s have never had such a thing unfortunately.

     

    i notice the change all the time. Something I always checked up on.

     

    I could actaully notice the difference between 160-190F on the factory gauge also.

     

    It a personal thing on what u would like. TBH if you have an autometer gauge which is already giving you an ACCURATE reading, I wouldn’t bother with the factory dash.

    #11248
    Profile photo of VRSenator065
    VRSenator065
    Participant
    • Adelaide SA
    • VR Senator LSx454 1960 Kombi (project) 1921 Nash Hot Rod (future project)

    • View build HERE
    Member since: February 17, 2015
    Posts: 5 777
    Supporter

    I’m not at home so I cant take a pic right now, but you can see from this the #6 pipe curls back around behind #8 and pretty much means there’s no way to fit the sensor and/or adapter.

    • This reply was modified 8 years, 11 months ago by Profile photo of VRSenator065 VRSenator065.
    #11252
    Profile photo of VRSenator065
    VRSenator065
    Participant
    • Adelaide SA
    • VR Senator LSx454 1960 Kombi (project) 1921 Nash Hot Rod (future project)

    • View build HERE
    Member since: February 17, 2015
    Posts: 5 777
    Supporter

    OK million dollar question, if I simply disconnect and remove the LS sensor, will the ECU crack a sad, or will it work as normal?

    #11253
    Profile photo of
    Anonymous Member since: January 1, 1970
    Posts: 0

    OK million dollar question, if I simply disconnect and remove the LS sensor, will the ECU crack a sad, or will it work as normal?

    It will go into a safe/limp mode..

    There are a bunch of tables that rely on the ECT sensor, if you’re talking about removing it for good NO bad idea..

    #11254
    Profile photo of VRSenator065
    VRSenator065
    Participant
    • Adelaide SA
    • VR Senator LSx454 1960 Kombi (project) 1921 Nash Hot Rod (future project)

    • View build HERE
    Member since: February 17, 2015
    Posts: 5 777
    Supporter

    OK thanks, screw that idea then.  Nope I am going to try it in the bottom hose.  I have the ultra gauge that maybe I will plug into the OBD port for the first couple of days, that way I can keep an eye on both to make sure its all kosher.

    #11255
    Profile photo of
    Anonymous Member since: January 1, 1970
    Posts: 0

    I’d still put it in the top hose and be done with it….

    That way it’ll read like stock and if you position it carefully won’t even know it’s there..

    Grab a spare hose and precut it so if you’re ever out anywhere and blow a hose it’s a simple swap/refill to get it home.

    Also be a good idea to measure whatever hose you decide on before buying the adaptor just to be 100% sure..

    #11256
    Profile photo of Immortality
    Immortality
    Participant
    Member since: August 31, 2015
    Posts: 535

    My theory is that as long as there is some coolant in the system and no airlock in the bottom hose it (the water pump) will continue to suck coolant from the radiator and force it into the engine so it (the engine) won’t show a major temperature fluctuation until all the coolant is lost in which case by the time you notice it will probably to late anyway. In reality, how often do you notice a change in engine temperature? How often do you check the gauge whilst you drive? If you want a 100% fool proof method you really need to set up a bright warning light that illuminates at a set temp. A much better option would be a low coolant sensor but Holden’s have never had such a thing unfortunately.

    i notice the change all the time. Something I always checked up on. I could actaully notice the difference between 160-190F on the factory gauge also. It a personal thing on what u would like. TBH if you have an autometer gauge which is already giving you an ACCURATE reading, I wouldn’t bother with the factory dash.

     

    VN-VS temp gauge I notice a difference in temps from thermostat open temp (82°C) and thermo fan on  temps (94°C, my settings) and see the gauge move as the thermo fan pulls the engine temps down.  However on the VX the gauge rarely moves once up to temp?

    I do check the gauge at certain times and more so when I’m expecting to see temps rise but I doubt I would see it move if it happened between checking things.

    I actually disagree with the modern driver training where you are taught to check the dash and mirrors every couple of seconds, to much time spent with you’re eyes off the road instead of watching what is ahead off you and oncoming traffic etc.  People are too distracted these days.

    #11257
    Profile photo of VRSenator065
    VRSenator065
    Participant
    • Adelaide SA
    • VR Senator LSx454 1960 Kombi (project) 1921 Nash Hot Rod (future project)

    • View build HERE
    Member since: February 17, 2015
    Posts: 5 777
    Supporter

    Well I do have the old two piece top hose that was on there until I found the current one piece, so i could use that.  I will give it some thought tomorrow and go one way or the other…

    #11258
    Profile photo of
    Anonymous Member since: January 1, 1970
    Posts: 0

    Thinking is a good thing!

    #11259
    Profile photo of VRSenator065
    VRSenator065
    Participant
    • Adelaide SA
    • VR Senator LSx454 1960 Kombi (project) 1921 Nash Hot Rod (future project)

    • View build HERE
    Member since: February 17, 2015
    Posts: 5 777
    Supporter

    Had a look when I got home, I think I have come up with a cunning plan m’lord.

    #11260
    Profile photo of
    Anonymous Member since: January 1, 1970
    Posts: 0

    Well done Balders…

    #11261
    Profile photo of Red1m8
    Red1m8
    Participant
    Member since: April 10, 2015
    Posts: 101

    What about tapping the flat spot on the water pump that some use as a steam pipe return for the factory sender .

    #11262
    Profile photo of
    Anonymous Member since: January 1, 1970
    Posts: 0

    What about tapping the flat spot on the water pump that some use as a steam pipe return for the factory sender .

    That’s on the cold side of the radiator.

Viewing 20 posts - 21 through 40 (of 43 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.